Stewart Rhodes Went to Prison for Trump. Now He Says He Is Done.
Stewart Rhodes served time for his role in the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. While he was in prison, he got a tattoo of Donald Trump’s face.
Now Rhodes says, “I am absolutely done with Trump.”
That is a strange sentence to read. Rhodes founded the Oath Keepers, a right-wing militia. He was convicted of seditious conspiracy for his part in the effort to keep Trump in power after the 2020 election. He received an 18-year sentence, among the longest given in Jan. 6 cases.
Trump later commuted Rhodes’s sentence. Rhodes was released in January 2025. But he says he did not receive the full pardon that Trump gave to hundreds of other Jan. 6 defendants.
For Rhodes, that difference mattered. He says it was the beginning of his break with Trump. “He let us out of prison. We were grateful. I didn’t get a pardon, though,” Rhodes told the Associated Press.
I read that and paused. Not because Rhodes has become a sympathetic figure. He has not. But because the story shows how personal political loyalty can become, and how quickly it can turn when a person feels left behind.
What Rhodes says now
Rhodes now calls Trump a traitor. He calls him “one of the very worst in our nation’s history.”
He also says he will have the Trump tattoo modified. “I will have this prison tattoo of Trump ‘modified’ to reflect that reality. That treason,” Rhodes said in a text message reported by the Associated Press.
The tattoo is the detail that stays with me. It was made while Rhodes was serving a sentence connected to Jan. 6. It was an act of devotion. Now it is a problem he says he wants changed.
That does not erase what Rhodes did. It does not make his earlier support less serious. It does show how much of politics can run on personal allegiance, especially when a leader becomes a symbol rather than a public servant.
What is documented
The documented facts are fairly narrow.
Rhodes was convicted of seditious conspiracy and other felony charges in connection with Jan. 6. He was sentenced to 18 years in prison. Trump commuted that sentence in January 2025, and Rhodes was released.
Earlier this year, the Justice Department vacated Rhodes’s conviction. That lifted his felony status. Rhodes says he is now working to rebuild the Oath Keepers, a group that once had tens of thousands of members, according to leaked lists.
Rhodes also says he did not register to vote in time for the election. He says his first priority after getting his rights back was to get guns.
Those are his statements. They describe his intentions. They do not tell us what he will actually do, how large any revived Oath Keepers organization will become, or how much influence he will have.
What remains unknown
It is easy to treat one man’s break with Trump as proof of a larger political shift. I understand the impulse. A former Jan. 6 leader turning away from the president is news.
But it is not yet proof of a broad realignment.
We know Rhodes is angry. We know he feels he was treated differently from other Jan. 6 defendants. We know he is speaking publicly about rebuilding the Oath Keepers. We do not know whether his views will spread, whether former allies will follow him, or whether this will change the political choices of ordinary voters.
The Associated Press describes Rhodes’s repudiation as another example of fading allegiance among extreme supporters. That is a reasonable observation from the reporting. It is not the same as saying Trump has lost a major part of his coalition.
There is a difference between a loud break and a lasting political movement. Rhodes has made a loud break. What comes next is unknown.
Why it matters
For most people, Jan. 6 is not an abstract argument about institutions. It was a day when a crowd attacked the Capitol, interrupted the certification of an election, and injured police officers. The consequences reached families, workplaces, courts, and communities.
Rhodes was part of that story. His conviction, sentence, commutation, and later public break with Trump are part of the same record.
When someone who went to prison for a political cause says he is done with its leader, it is worth paying attention. Not because his anger deserves celebration. It does not. But because it is a reminder that political movements are held together by more than ideas.
They are held together by promises, favors, status, fear, and the belief that someone will protect you.
Rhodes believed Trump would protect him. He says Trump did not do enough. That belief has changed. The tattoo remains, at least for now.
The question is not whether Rhodes has become a different kind of political figure. The question is whether other people who once saw Trump as their protector will begin to ask the same question.
More on: Politics